Closed Today

Der Dutchman - Sarasota


Something warm, wonderful and homemade is always coming out of the oven in our bustling Amish kitchen.

Bakery Menu

Seasonal Specials

  • Lemon Meringue Pie
  • Lemon Donuts
  • Lemon Long Johns
  • Lemon Poppy Seed Muffins
  • Fresh Blueberry Pie

Café Drink Specials

  • Cold Brew with Sweet Cream
  • Lavender Lemonade
  • Lavender Honey Latte


Lemon Cream Sticks

Birthday, Anniversary & Wedding Cakes

Pre-order your special occasion cakes or select a ready-made one from our showcase. Our decorators can personalize your cake in minutes.

  • Birthday
  • Anniversary
  • Wedding
  • Bridal and Baby Showers
  • Retirement
  • Reunions
  • Graduation

Available in layer cakes or sheetcakes. Stop in or call to place a cake order, 941-955-8007.

Cake Brochure

Bakery Partners

Find Der Dutchman baked goods available at or served by these Sarasota area establishments. Find our partners 

Perq Coffee Bar
1821 Hillview St. Sarasota, 34239

Snow’s Country Market

6906 Lecanto Highway
Beverly Hills, Florida


Jersey Girl Bagels
5275 University Pkwy,
Sarasota, Florida

Somethings just go together...that's the case with our Der Dutchman Amish Peanut Butter Spread and our fresh-baked Dinner Rolls. This traditional combo is often served for lunch at Amish Church services and is a great snack for kids.

A great gift idea!

Join Our Team

We value people who value people. Be part of a positive work environment that offers many opportunities for growth.

Job Opportunities

Buy Gift Cards

A great gift for any occasion, Dutchman Hospitality gift cards can be used at any of our restaurants, shops or inns.

Shop Online