We now have a donut truck! Visit The Rolling Dutchman’s page here to see where it will be next!

Open Today
9:00 am - 8:00 pm

Plain City, OH

Carlisle Gifts

divider icon

Welcome To Our Shop

No trip to Der Dutchman is complete without a visit to Carlisle Gifts. 

This gem of a store is located just steps from our bakery and features a variety of home decor, crafts, apparel, and more.

Store Information

women shopping in dutch carlisle gifts

What's In Store

From trendy jewelry and handbags to whimsical items for your home, you’re sure to find something that will make you smile. Enjoy our wide variety of seasonal items, or pick out the perfect outfit for your next special occasion.

tiny lit candles

Carlisle Gifts - Plain City

Visit

Carlisle Gifts - Plain City

445 S Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH, USA

Get Directions Virtual Tour

Contact

Phone

614-873-1332

Hours

Gift Shop

Monday - Thursday: 9 am - 7 pm

Friday - Saturday: 9 am - 8 pm

Sunday: Closed

Holiday Hours

Labor Day

9 am - 2 pm

Follow Us

Come and Join Us

Setting the mood

Traditional and flameless candles and candle warmers

Live Your Best Life

While looking through all of our home decor.

Fun for the Family

Fun toys for kids (and adults!)

Your handbag makes the outfit

Colorful patterns and styles to complement any outfit.

woodwick candles
retro toy cars

Setting the mood

Traditional and flameless candles and candle warmers

woodwick candles

Setting the mood

Traditional and flameless candles and candle warmers

Live Your Best Life

While looking through all of our home decor.

Live Your Best Life

While looking through all of our home decor.

Fun for the Family

Fun toys for kids (and adults!)

retro toy cars

Fun for the Family

Fun toys for kids (and adults!)

Your handbag makes the outfit

Colorful patterns and styles to complement any outfit.

Your handbag makes the outfit

Colorful patterns and styles to complement any outfit.