Skip to content

If you are experiencing issues trying to purchase an item or gift card please call Connie at 330-852-2631 ext. 1217. Monday-Friday 9am-5pm.

 

Go to Homepage
  • Make a Reservation
    • Make a Reservation
    • Carlisle Inn at Walnut Creek exterior sunset
      Walnut Creek
    • Sarasota
    • Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek exterior entrance sign
      Sugarcreek
    • Essenhaus Inns and pond
      Essenhaus
    • Miller Manor
  • Order Online
    • Order Online
    • Sugarcreek
    • Walnut Creek
    • Bellville
    • Plain City
    • Sarasota
    • Essenhaus
  • About Us
  • Shop Online
    • Shop Online
    • Dutch Valley Market in Sugarcreek
      Dutchman Online
    • Essenhaus village gift shop outside
      Essenhaus Market
  • Careers
Buy Tickets
    • Ohio
      • Berlin Farmstead
      • Der Dutchman Bellville
      • Der Dutchman Plain City
      • Der Dutchman Walnut Creek
      • Dutch Valley Sugarcreek
    • Indiana
      • Das Dutchman Essenhaus
    • Florida
      • Der Dutchman Sarasota
    • All Restaurants
    • Ohio
      • Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek
      • Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek
      • Miller Manor
    • Indiana
      • Essenhaus Inn & Conference Center
    • Florida
      • Carlisle Inn Sarasota
    • All Inns
    • Ohio
      • Carlisle Gifts Bellville
      • Carlisle Gifts Plain City
      • Carlisle Gifts Walnut Creek
      • Dutch Valley Gifts Sugarcreek
    • Indiana
      • Essenhaus Village Shops
    • Florida
      • Carlisle Gifts Sarasota
    • All Shops
  • Theater
  • Market
  • Locations
    • Walnut Creek
    • Sarasota
    • Sugarcreek
    • Essenhaus
    • Miller Manor
    • Sugarcreek
    • Walnut Creek
    • Bellville
    • Plain City
    • Sarasota
    • Essenhaus
  • About Us
    • Dutchman Online
    • Essenhaus Market
  • Careers
  • Restaurants
    • The Chosen: Season 3 Finale
      The Chosen: Season 3 Finale
    • All Restaurants
    • Ohio
      • Berlin Farmstead
      • Der Dutchman Bellville
      • Der Dutchman Plain City
      • Der Dutchman Walnut Creek
      • Dutch Valley Sugarcreek
    • Indiana
      • Das Dutchman Essenhaus
    • Florida
      • Der Dutchman Sarasota
  • Inns
    • All Inns
    • Ohio
      • Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek
      • Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek
      • Miller Manor
    • Indiana
      • Essenhaus Inn & Conference Center
    • Florida
      • Carlisle Inn Sarasota
  • Shops
    • All Shops
    • Ohio
      • Carlisle Gifts Bellville
      • Carlisle Gifts Plain City
      • Carlisle Gifts Walnut Creek
      • Dutch Valley Gifts Sugarcreek
    • Indiana
      • Essenhaus Village Shops
    • Florida
      • Carlisle Gifts Sarasota
  • Theater
  • Market
  • Locations
Food Gifts Gift Cards Login/Register Cart

Category: Amish Bakery

Monster Cookies
View Item
Monster Cookies

$17.99

MSRP:

Chocolate Chip Whoopie Pie Cookies
View Item
Chocolate Chip Whoopie Pie Cookies

$29.99

MSRP:

Dutchman Cookie Dough
View Item
Dutchman Cookie Dough

$17.99

MSRP:

Amish Fry Pie Sampler
View Item
Amish Fry Pie Sampler

$37.99

MSRP:

Classic Blueberry Pie
View Item
Classic Blueberry Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

Chocolate Brownies
View Item
Chocolate Brownies

$9.99

MSRP:

Homemade Cinnamon Rolls
View Item
Homemade Cinnamon Rolls

$12.99

MSRP:

Amish Fry Pies
View Item
Amish Fry Pies

$21.99

MSRP:

Amish Long Johns or Creamsticks
View Item
Amish Long Johns or Creamsticks

$13.99

MSRP:

Amish Pumpkin Pie
View Item
Amish Pumpkin Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

Country Apple Pie
View Item
Country Apple Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

Country Black Raspberry Pie
View Item
Country Black Raspberry Pie

$25.99

MSRP:

Country Cherry Pie
View Item
Country Cherry Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

Country Peach Pie
View Item
Country Peach Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

Dutch Apple Crumb-topped Pie
View Item
Dutch Apple Crumb-topped Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

Dutch Cherry Crumb-topped Pie
View Item
Dutch Cherry Crumb-topped Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

No Sugar Added Apple Pie
View Item
No Sugar Added Apple Pie

$22.99

MSRP:

Pecan Pie
View Item
Pecan Pie

$24.99

MSRP:

Amish Pumpkin Cake Roll
View Item
Amish Pumpkin Cake Roll

$21.99

MSRP:

Butterscotch Cream Pie Kit
View Item
Butterscotch Cream Pie Kit

$22.99

MSRP:

Chocolate Cream Pie Kit
View Item
Chocolate Cream Pie Kit

$22.99

MSRP:

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie Kit
View Item
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie Kit

$22.99

MSRP:

Coconut Cream Pie Kit
View Item
Coconut Cream Pie Kit

$22.99

MSRP:

Homemade Angel Food Cake
View Item
Homemade Angel Food Cake

$17.99

MSRP:

Peanut Butter Cream Pie Kit
View Item
Peanut Butter Cream Pie Kit

$22.99

MSRP:

Posts navigation

Page 1 Page 2 Next page
  • Restaurants
  • Shops
  • Inns
  • Theater
  • Market
  • Locations
  • Events
  • Shop Online
Go to Homepage

Mail

PO Box 158

Walnut Creek, OH 44687

Office

4985 State Route 515

Millersburg, OH 44654

Sign up for News

Subscribe

Follow Us

facebook
  • Restaurants
    • Dutch Valley Sugarcreek
    • Der Dutchman Walnut Creek
    • Berlin Farmstead
    • Der Dutchman Bellville
    • Der Dutchman Plain City
    • Der Dutchman Sarasota
    • Das Dutchman Essenhaus
  • Inns
    • Carlisle Inn Sarasota
    • Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek
    • Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek
    • Essenhaus Inn & Conference Center
    • Miller Manor
  • Shops
    • Dutch Valley Gifts Sugarcreek
    • Carlisle Gifts Walnut Creek
    • Carlisle Gifts Bellville
    • Carlisle Gifts Plain City
    • Carlisle Gifts Sarasota
    • Essenhaus Village Shops
  • Theater
  • Market
  • Locations
  • Events
  • Careers

Copyright © 2023 Dutchman Hospitality Group - All rights reserved

  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Privacy