Search
Menu
It’s the Most, Wonderful Meal of the Year
Expect the unexpected when strangers and kinfolk show up in the middle of both a snowstorm and a life storm, and no one is left the same.
This not-so-traditional, sports-centered, laughter-filled Christmas dinner features favorite Christmas carols and original songs, too. Brought to you by the same team behind our other three hit musicals, The Confession, Half-Stitched, and Josiah for President, Dan Posthuma, Wally Nason, and Martha Bolton.
ABOUT THE PLAYWRIGHT
The author of the novel and play, Josiah for President, Martha Bolton was a staff writer for Bob Hope for more than 15 years and has written for other artists such as Mark Lowery, Jeff Allen and Phyllis Diller.
With over 40 books to her name, she's also written for Focus on the Family as well as parody lyrics of songs from Michael W. Smith, Steven Curtis Chapman and Amy Grant.
Martha began her comedy-writing career as a church secretary. "I saw a lot of comedy in the church," Martha says with a laugh. "I used to perform a Friar's Club-type roast on the pastor, deacon, or any other church staff member who was celebrating a special occasion. I had to change churches a lot." And thus began Martha's writing career. She's been going strong ever since.
Box Office - 855-344-7547
SHOW KEY:
(M) indicates a Blue Gate Musical
Blue Text indicates a Concert
JUNE 2017
| Date | Times | Show |
| Jun 1 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 2 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 3 |
7pm |
Home Game (M) |
| Jun 6 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 7 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 8 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 9 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 13 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 14 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 15 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 16 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 17 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 20 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 21 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 22 |
1pm |
Home Game (M) |
| Jun 23 | 1pm 7pm |
Ernie Haase & Signature Sound + David Pendleton |
| Jun 24 | 1pm 7pm |
Selah + David Pendleton |
| Jun 27 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 28 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 29 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jun 30 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
July 2017
| Date | Time | Show |
| Jul 6 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 7 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 11 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 12 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 13 | 1pm 7pm |
Home Game (M) |
| Jul 14 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 15 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 18 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 18 | 7pm | Michael English & Russ Taff |
| Jul 19 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 20 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 21 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 22 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 25 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 26 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 27 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 28 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Jul 29 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
August 2017
| Date | Time | Show |
| Aug 1 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 2 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 2 | 7pm | Gospel Harmony Boys |
| Aug 3 | 1pm 7pm |
Home Game (M) |
| Aug 4 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 5 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 8 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 9 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 10 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 11 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 12 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 15 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 16 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 17 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 18 | 7pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 19 | 1pm | Home Game (M) |
| Aug 29 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Aug 30 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Aug 31 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Aug 31 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
September 2017
| Date | Time | Show |
| Sep 1 | 7pm | Mark Lowry |
| Sep 2 | 1pm | Mark Lowry |
| Sep 2 | 7pm | Mark Lowry |
| Sep 5 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 6 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 7 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 8 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 8 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 9 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 9 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 12 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 12 | 7pm | Gospel Harmony Boys |
| Sep 13 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 13 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 14 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 15 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 15 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 16 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 16 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 19 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 20 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 20 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 21 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 21 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 22 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 23 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 23 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 26 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 26 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 27 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sept 27 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 28 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 29 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 29 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Sep 30 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Sep 30 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
October 2017
| Date | Time | Show |
| Oct 3 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 4 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 5 |
1pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 5 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 6 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 6 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 7 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 7 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 10 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 11 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 11 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 12 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 12 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 13 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 13 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 14 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 14 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 17 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 18 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 19 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 19 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 20 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 20 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 21 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 21 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 23 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 24 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 25 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 26 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 26 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 27 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Oct 27 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 28 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Oct 28 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
November 2017
| Date | Time | Show |
| Nov 1 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Nov 1 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Nov 2 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Nov 2 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Nov 3 | 1pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Nov 3 | 7pm | Confession (M) |
| Nov 4 | 1pm | Confession (M) |
| Nov 4 | 7pm | Menno Girls Can Cook (M) |
| Nov 9 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 10 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 11 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 14 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 15 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 16 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 17 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 18 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 24 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 25 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 28 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Nov 30 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
December 2017
| Date | Time | Show |
| Dec 1 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 2 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 5 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 5 | 7pm | Steve Green |
| Dec 6 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 6 | 7pm | Steve Green |
| Dec 7 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 8 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 9 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 12 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 13 | 1pm | Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 14 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 15 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 16 | 1pm 7pm |
Our Christmas Dinner (M) |
| Dec 30 | 1pm 9pm |
New Year's Eve TBD |
2018 season
| Feb 9 | 7pm | Valentine Show Steve & Annie Chapman |
| Feb 10 | 7pm | Valentine Show Steve & Annie Chapman |
Request Group Rates
How can we help create memories for your group? Contact us to learn about special rates and packages for groups. Email Group Sales or call 855-344-7547.
Good to Know
About Meal Packages: With Buffet/Family-style Meals, the cost shown includes your ticket, meal, beverage, tax and gratuity. Choose to eat at any Amish Country Dutchman Hospitality restaurant — Dutch Valley (Sugarcreek), Der Dutchman (Walnut Creek), or Berlin Farmstead (Berlin).
About Overnight Packages: Choose to stay at any Amish Country Dutchman Hospitality inn —
Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek, Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek or Carlisle Country Inn Berlin. Please contact our group sales staff to arrange an overnight stay at 855-344-7547.
Tickets Only
| Monday–Saturday | Ticket Only | Ticket w/Room |
|---|---|---|
| Group of 20+ Receive 1 comp ticket |
$38.00 | $33.00 |
| Group of 30+ Receive 2 comp tickets |
$36.00 | $31.00 |
Tickets with buffet or family style meal
| Monday–Saturday | Ticket Only | Ticket w/Room |
|---|---|---|
| Group of 20+ Receive 1 comp ticket |
$55.50 | $53.50 |
| Group of 30+ Receive 2 comp tickets |
$50.50 | $48.50 |
Two Shows Package Deal
See two out of three shows: The Home Game, The Confession Musical & Mennonite Girls Can Cook
| Monday–Saturday | Ticket Only | Ticket w/Room |
|---|---|---|
| Group of 20+ Receive 1 comp ticket |
$60.00 | $55.00 |
|
Group of 30+ |
$58.00 | $53.00 |
SEE TWO SHOWS WITH buffet or family style meal
| Monday–Saturday | Ticket Only | Ticket w/Room |
|---|---|---|
| Group of 20+ Receive 1 comp ticket |
$77.50 | $75.50 |
| Group of 30+ Receive 2 comp tickets | $72.50 | $70.50 |
Please book your show tickets at the Ohio Star Theater below. Ticket and Meal combination packages may be purchased also.
